top of page

HMRC Wins First Tier Tribunal Case on Contested Residential SDLT Charge

James George Gibson appealed against a closure notice from HMRC regarding a property named Doe Bank Manor. The notice issued last year demanded an additional £83,000 for Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT).


Some key details about the property and the case:


1. Property Details:


• Purchased for £1,595,000 on 10 January 2019.


• Gibson and his family occupied it from 27 November 2018.


• Features include a six-bedroom house, a double garage with an office, a two-bedroom self-contained barn, two stables, and a two-acre paddock.


• Previously, the property had farm buildings, a farmyard, and a market garden. Now, these areas are in disuse.


• Adjoining proprietors, CHR Ventures Ltd and Paul and Rosemary Hobday, had an informal grazing agreement for the paddock.


2. SDLT Dispute:


• Gibson's initial SDLT return labelled the property as ‘mixed-use’ with a tax due of £69,500.


• However, HMRC decided the property was entirely residential, which meant higher SDLT rates, totalling £153,000.


• Gibson didn’t claim multiple dwellings relief (MDR) initially. But on 20 December 2020, he argued its eligibility since the house and barn had separate amenities and addresses.


3. Evidence & Claims:


• Gibson provided evidence of the property's use for grazing and its historical agricultural significance.


• He referred to a pre-purchase visit and brochure photographs showing grazing sheep.


• An agreement with adjoining proprietors stated that the paddock was used for grazing for at least four years before Gibson's purchase.


4. HMRC's Counter Argument:


• At the time of the transaction, the property was solely residential.


• The paddock’s grazing was informal, serving to maintain the rural ambience rather than for commercial exploitation.


5. Judge's Ruling:


• Judge Gemmell WS believed that the paddock did not serve a significant commercial purpose, making it hard to classify the property as mixed residential and non-residential.


• Regarding the MDR, HMRC argued Gibson's claim was tardy and lacked evidence. The First-tier Tribunal (FTT) agreed, noting that Gibson didn’t amend his SDLT return timely. As a result, his appeal was denied.


Contacts

If you require assistance in relation to the above and/or would like to discuss anything further, please do not hesitate to contact info@act.london or your usual A.C.T. contact.

 
 
 

Comentários


LONDON

27 Hill Street

Mayfair

London W1J 45

UK

Tel: +44 (0) 207 432 6050

Email: info@act.london

DUBLIN

Mespil House

Sussex Road

Dublin 4

Ireland

Tel: +353 (0) 1231 4639

Email: dublin@act.london

DUBAI

Level 3, Boulevard Plaza Tower 1,

Sheikh Mohamed Bin Rashid Boulevard

Downtown Dubai 

UAE

Tel: +971 (0) 4425 7368

Email: dubai@act.london

MONACO

24 Bd. Princesse Charlotte
MC 98000

Monte Carlo

Monaco

Tel: +377 9350 5256 

Email: monaco@act.london

Copyright 2016 - 2020 Website by ACT London Limited |  Privacy Statement   |  Cookies Policy |   All Rights Reserved

A.C.T. London Limited is a private limited company registered in England and Wales under registration number 04505457.

Its registered office is at Berkeley Suite, 35 Berkeley Square, Mayfair, London, W1J 5BF, United Kingdom.

A.C.T. London Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (No. 1019714).

ICAEW_CharteredAccountants_WHT_RGB.png
bottom of page